Case, Hiram S. (1814–1882)

By Michael W. Campbell

×

Michael W. Campbell, Ph.D., is North American Division Archives, Statistics, and Research director. Previously, he was professor of church history and systematic theology at Southwestern Adventist University. An ordained minister, he pastored in Colorado and Kansas. He is assistant editor of The Ellen G. White Encyclopedia (Review and Herald, 2013) and currently is co-editor of the forthcoming Oxford Handbook of Seventh-day Adventism. He also taught at the Adventist International Institute for Advanced Studies (2013-18) and recently wrote the Pocket Dictionary for Understanding Adventism (Pacific Press, 2020).

First Published: July 23, 2026 | Last Updated: November 3, 2026

Hiram S. Case was a Millerite adherent, evangelist, the first minister to preach the Sabbatarian Adventist faith in Wisconsin and Ohio, and co-founder of the Messenger Party, the first organized schism from the nascent Seventh-day Adventist movement.

Early Life and Ministry

Hiram S. Case was born October 14, 1814, in New Lebanon, New York, to William (1786-1859) and Betsey (1792-1886) Case. Case married Rebecca A. Mentline (1816-1887). They had four children: Savilla (1835-1869), Marion (b. 1841), Adelbert (b. 1851), and Emma (1853-1870).1 In the 1830s, he moved to Michigan, where he worked as a farmer and blacksmith.2

Sabbatarian Adventist Evangelist

During the summer of 1850, Samuel Rhodes (1810-1883) and John C. Bowles (1800-1853) traveled across Michigan sharing their Sabbatarian Adventist faith. In North Plains, Michigan, they converted Case, who exclaimed: “This truth ravishes my soul. . . . Glory to God! I feel the truth in my soul, like fire shut up in my bones.”3 Although Case had accepted the Second Advent doctrine in 1844, after the Great Disappointment, he had, in his words, “fallen into the ‘ditch.”4 According to Case, Rhodes spent a few days teaching him about “the third angel’s message more perfectly.”5 Case and George W. Holt (1812-1877) were the earliest Sabbatarian Adventists to clearly identify the two horns of the lamblike beast in Revelation 13:11-18 as the Protestant churches and a republican nation.6 He wrote:

While Bro. Rhodes was showing me the third angel’s message, the light in relation to the two horned beast, Rev. xiii, 11, came to my mind all at once, and to me the thing is clear that the two horned beast is the power of Church and State. It is an “image” of the Papal Beast to whom the dragon “gave his power, and his seat, and great authority.” The Papal Beast was church and state united. An image must be like the thing imitated; therefore, the image-beast is composed of church and state united—Protestant churches and Republicanism. The word of the Lord is plain.7

Case catalyzed a growing consensus among Sabbatarian Adventists on the text's meaning. The following year, J. N. Andrews wrote about America as the “lamblike beast” that spoke “like a dragon” (Rev. 13:11).8

In October 1851, J. B. Bezzo reported that Case created a prophetic chart based on his interpretations, but it apparently caused division. Case had to apologize for his chart.9 Rhodes had also created a chart, as well as Otis Nichols (1798-1876), whose chart became the standard version.10

Case spent the ensuing years actively encouraging former Millerites to return to their belief in Jesus’ soon return and to convert others to Sabbatarian Adventism. In 1851, he traveled around New York to encourage former Millerite believers (“those who started for the kingdom in ’43 and ’44”).11 In April 1851, he stopped in Cleveland, Akron, and Cincinnati to hold meetings and distribute literature.12 James White (1821-1881) mentioned Hiram’s trip to Ohio as noteworthy because of the fledgling group’s expansion into new territory.13 His trip reportedly resulted in three baptisms, and Case left a chart for Waterman Phelps (1814-1874) to encourage him to study further and share his faith.14

By early 1852, Case wrote from his home in Jackson, Michigan. Jackson became the birthplace of Sabbatarian Adventism in Michigan.15 In 1852, he reported on a visit by Joseph Bates, who came “richly laden with the truth” for their “hungry souls.”16 In September, Case organized conferences in North Plains and Tyrone, Michigan (the latter with John Preston Kellogg [1807-1881]).17 In November 1852, he reported on an evangelistic tour to Madison, Wisconsin. Joseph H. Waggoner (1820-1889) later recalled an 1852 visit by Case with Phelps in his home during which they shared with him the “present truth.”18 This would be especially notable since this resulted in the conversion of Waggoner and his family, who became especially noteworthy through their influence in early Sabbatarian Adventism.

In 1853, Case worked closely with Merritt E. Cornell (1827-1893), laboring “ardently, and God has blest their efforts,” James White reported.19 White added that even though Case behaved appropriately by not publicly castigating Marsh, Marsh had attempted to destroy him in the pages of the Harbinger. Marsh’s opposition of Case had “only served to open the way before him, while he has humbly followed on in the work of his Master, and success has followed.”20 In January 1853, he reported that he had given ten lectures in Grand Rapids, Michigan, the first Sabbatarian Adventist to share his beliefs there.”21 He then left with Merritt G. Kellogg (1832-1921) for Bedford, embarking on a lengthy preaching tour.22 By August 1853, his postal address was listed as Jackson, Michigan, suggesting that he had concluded his tour.23

“Offended for a Word”

In 1853, a church conflict erupted in the Jackson congregation between Case’s daughter, Savilla, and their neighbor, Abigail Palmer (1823-1892), wife of Dan Palmer (1817-1897). During a verbal altercation, Savilla believed she heard Palmer call her a “bitch.”24 Palmer later claimed she never said the word, even though she later admitted to having used the word “witch.”25 A conflict ensued between the two women and involved the congregation with some taking sides in the dispute. During a meeting at Jackson, Ellen White had a vision on the dispute between the two women. Hiram Case and Charles P. Russell (1810-1880)—an active local church leader and glove maker—had been the primary agitators criticizing Palmer. When Ellen White publicly admonished Palmer after the vision, Case and Russell affirmed their belief that White’s prophecy was God-given and urged Palmer to repent.26 As Ellen White gave her testimony, they cried out, “Amen! Amen!” and “I thought so!”27 They were so enthusiastic against Palmer that Ellen White became concerned but finished the rest of the testimony, while James White reproved Case and Russell for their negative attitude.28 That night Ellen White received another vision in which she was shown that Case and Russell’s unchristian spirits were causing division. She wrote, “I saw why the Lord had hid from me the part of the vision that related to them. It was that they might have opportunity to manifest before all what spirit they were of.”29 While Palmer repented after being rebuked by White, when Case and Russell were admonished, they became “incensed” over the “rebuke.”30

Separation

By February 17, 1854, in a regional meeting, a group of believers stated that they had reviewed the “qualification of H. S. Case as a religious teacher.” It declared it their “painful duty . . . that we no longer consider him qualified to travel and teach the third angel’s message.”31 The statement was signed by Abram A. Dodge (1817-1892), Stephen T. Cranson (1822-1855), Cyrenius Smith (1804-1874), John Preston Kellogg, Charles S. Glover (1814-1920), L. Fitch, Henry Lyon (1796-1872), and A. Avery.32

In 1854, James White reported on a visit to Jackson, Michigan. He wrote about an “unpleasant” encounter with Case who “was annoying and unchristian.” He stated that Case would interrupt meetings, distract participants, and make “railing accusations” against the Whites, and finally, had “withdrawn fellowship.”33 Ellen White’s strongest criticism of Case was as follows:

No gentleman, to say nothing of his profession as a Christian, and a minister of Christ, would be found in the position occupied by him. . . . The cause in Michigan has suffered much in time past by the injudicious course pursued by H. S. Case. He has given the opposers of the truth a chance to raise and circulate reports unfavorable to those who keep the Sabbath. He has been a source of constant trial for years. He has been patiently borne with, and has been admonished and labored with by those who have felt deeply for the cause, and have felt wounded by his course. His brethren have borne with him, hoping that he would reform; but it is evident that the church have erred by holding him in fellowship so long. We pity the man, and mention his course only to warn those who may be in danger of suffering from his malicious influence.34

Another conflict had arisen the previous year between Case and the Whites when Case charged the Whites with “speculation” for financially benefiting from the sale of Bibles. White countered that they had shipped Case a box of Bibles at a loss (it cost him $7.50 and Case paid only $6.00), and that Case had even made one to two shillings in his sale of the Bibles. White felt it was deeply unfair to charge the Whites with making money when Case was the only one who had made money on the Bible.35 Other points of contention, according to Dores E. Robinson, included “exclusive views relative to the shut door” and Case’s tendency toward “a rash spirit.”36

Case subsequently organized the Messenger Party, which split homes in their community with some joining this divergent party and others remaining with the fledgling Sabbatarian Adventist movement. The first issue of their periodical, The Messenger of Truth, appeared in September 1854.37 In the three extant issues, the party raised objections to Ellen White’s prophetic claims. First, they argued that Adventists, by believing in Ellen White’s prophecies, had another rule of faith and practice in addition to the Bible. Second, the party argued that the prophetic gift ceased in apostolic times. Third, they argued that the “testimony of Jesus” in Revelation 12:17 had nothing to do with the prophetic gift but was instead the spirit of Christ that the true remnant had to represent. And last, the party accused Adventists of making Ellen White’s prophetic gift a “test of fellowship” and “rule of action.”

The Messenger party seemed to splinter quickly. “The Messenger party soon began to quarrel among themselves,” recalled George States, “and father, becoming disgusted, gave up all profession of religion.”38 But they did have a longer-term impact on the Sabbatarian Adventism work in Wisconsin leading to “prejudice . . . against the truth.”39 According to White, through the “judicious labors” of J. H. Waggoner among others, they had been able to stabilize the fledgling work there. Similarly, church leaders worked in Michigan to settle disputes and build the church. About half the local congregation followed Case. As George States recalled:

For a time it looked very discouraging, and the time of our loyal ministers was occupied in exposing the falsehoods which were uttered by the Messenger party. As fast as one falsehood was exposed, another was invented, and we thought surely that must be exposed. About this time Sister White was shown that if we could keep at our work, preaching the truth regardless of any such people as the Messenger party, they would yet go to war among themselves, and soon our numbers would be doubled. Following this instruction from the Lord, our work advanced as never before, and the leaders in the opposition began quarreling among themselves. The leader, H. S. Case, soon gave up the Sabbath, and for years lived in northern Michigan, working at fishing. He became a very profane man, and died in that condition.40

By late 1857, the Messenger party had largely scattered due to internal disagreements, lack of financial support, and shifting allegiances. In 1858 James White described Case as “run out as a preacher, and fishing on the lakes.”41

Legacy

While little is known about Case’s later life, reports indicate he went into real estate. The 1860 census indicates he was worth a substantial $4,000 in land holdings, and he later inherited more land after his father’s death.42 One report suggested that he was declared insane at some point later in life.43 He died on April 24, 1882, and is buried in the Pioneer Cemetery in Hartford, Michigan.44

Case stopped preaching in his later years.45 Gilbert Granmer (1814-1903) formed his own breakaway group which became the Church of God (Seventh Day) in 1863. Some people involved in The Messenger began supporting his publication, The Hope of Israel, printed on the same press as The Messenger, showing the connections among those opposed to the fledgling denomination.

Arthur W. Spalding (1877-1953) described this split as the “first concerted disaffection” in Adventist history.46 The controversy surrounding Case’s separation contributed to further discussions about “church order.” These included discussions about how to pay and authorize preachers and became a major catalyst for conversations in the 1850s and early 1860s that led to formal church organization.47

Sources

Bezzo, J. B. “H. S. Case.” The Messenger of Truth, November 2, 1854.

Campbell, Michael W. “Bible Conferences, 1848-1851.” In the Encyclopedia of Seventh-day Adventists, First published February 1, 2024. https://encyclopedia.adventist.org/article?id=BIR3&highlight=bible|conferences.

Campbell, Michael W. and Edward Martin Allen. A Global History of Seventh-day Adventists. Grand Rapids, MI: Eerdmans, 2026.

Case, H. S. “From Bro. Case.” ARH, July 22, 1852.

Case, H. S. “From Bro. Case.” ARH, February 17, 1853.

Case, H. S. “Letter from Bro. Case.” Present Truth, November 1850.

The Ellen G. White Letters & Manuscripts with Annotations, 1845-1859, vol. 1. Hagerstown, MD: Review and Herald, 2014.

Froom, LeRoy Edwin. Movement of Destiny. Washington, D.C.: Review and Herald, 1971.

Froom, LeRoy Edwin. Prophetic Faith of Our Fathers: The Historical Development of Prophetic Interpretation, vol. 4. Washington, D.C.: Review and Herald, 1954.

Gilbert, F. C. Divine Predictions of Mrs. Ellen G. White Fulfilled. South Lancaster, MA: Good Tidings Press, 1922.

Gordon, Paul A. “Messengers of Error: A Story from the 1850s Reminds us that History Repeats.” ARH, March 5, 1992.

“H. S. Case.” ARH, April 18, 1854.

Lindsay, Allan G. “Thankful for These Stones: How God Worked to Build Up His Remnant People.” ARH, November 23, 2000.

Loughborough, J. N. The Great Second Advent Movement: Its Rise and Progress. Washington, DC: Review and Herald, 1909.

Loughborough, J. N. Rise and Progress of the Seventh-day Adventists with Tokens of God’s Hand in the Movement and A Brief Sketch of the Advent Cause from 1831 to 1844. Battle Creek, MI: General Conference Association of the Seventh-day Adventists, 1892.

Loughborough, J. N. “Some Individual Experience.” unpublished manuscript, circa 1919.

The Messenger of Truth, October 19, 1854. https://cdm.llu.edu/digital/collection/bftmm/id/72.

The Messenger of Truth, November 2, 1854. https://cdm.llu.edu/digital/collection/bftmm/id/77/.

The Messenger of Truth, November 30, 1854. https://archive.org/details/messengerof-truth/page/14/mode/2up.

Olsen, M. Ellsworth. A History of the Origin and Progress of Seventh-day Adventists, 2nd ed. Washington, D.C.: Review and Herald, 1926.

Pettibone, Dennis. “The Messenger Party.” ARH, January 23, 1975.

Spalding, Arthur Whitefield. Captains of the Host: First Volume of a History of Seventh-day Adventists Covering the Years 1845-1900. Washington, D.C.: Review and Herald, 1949.

Robinson, Dores E. “The Signatory Referred to.” The Ministry, June 1939.

States, George O. “Early Recollections in the Third Angel’s Message.” ARH, January 7, 1902.

States, George O. “Lessons from Past Experiences—No. 1.” ARH, August 2, 1906.

States, George O. “Lessons from Past Experiences—No. 2.” ARH, August 9, 1906.

Strayer, Brian E. “The First Church Built by Sabbathkeeping Adventists.” ARH, March 2, 1989.

United States Federal Census, 1840-1880.

W[aggoner], J. H. “The Third Angel’s Message: Fourth Paper.” ARH, April 10, 1883.

White, Arthur L. Ellen G. White: The Early Years: 1827-1862, vol. 1. Hagerstown, MD: Review and Herald, 1985.

White, Ellen G. Spiritual Gifts: My Christian Experience, Views and Labors, in Connection with the Rise and Progress of the Third Angel’s Message, vol. 2. Battle Creek, MI: James White, 1860.

White, Ellen G. “A Vision Given at Jackson, Michigan, June 2, 1853.” Manuscript 1, 1853.

W[hite], J[ames]. “A Sketch of the Rise and Progress of the Present Truth.” ARH, January 14, 1858.

White, James. “Western Tour.” ARH, June 9, 1853.

White, James. “Western Tour.” ARH, May 23, 1854.

White, James. “Western Tour.” ARH, July 4, 1854.

Notes

  1. For genealogical information, see: “Case Family Tree,” Ancestry. Last modified July 1, 2026, https://www.ancestry.com/invite-ui/accept?token=PatbSLMYAZ3nJmk9yoU6wegwQNGZ7Iln2j5uYDN_fGg=.↩

  2. Ellen White, The Ellen G. White Letters & Manuscripts with Annotations, 1845-1859 (Hagerstown, MD: Review and Herald, 2014), 1:805.↩

  3. H. S. Case, “Letter from Bro. Case,” The Present Truth, November 1850, 85.↩

  4. Ibid.↩

  5. See under “Bro. H. S. Case Writes…” in ARH, December 1850, 16.↩

  6. Geo[rge] W. Holt, “Letter from Bro. Holt,” The Present Truth, March 1850, 64; H. S. Case, “Letter from Bro. Case,” The Present Truth, November 1850, 85; LeRoy Edwin Froom, Movement of Destiny (Washington, D.C.: Review and Herald, 1971), 123.↩

  7. H. S. Case, “Letter from Bro. Case,” Present Truth, November 1850, 85. For more context, see LeRoy Edwin Froom, Prophetic Faith of Our Fathers: The Historical Development of Prophetic Interpretation (Washington, D.C.: Review and Herald, 1954), 4:1099.↩

  8. J. N. Andrews, “Thoughts on Revelation XIII and XIV,” Second Advent Review, and Sabbath Herald, May 19, 1851, 84; Joseph Bates, Second Advent Way Marks and High Heaps (New Bedford, MA: Benjamin Lindsey, 1847), 69-70.↩

  9. J. B. Bezzo, “H. S. Case,” The Messenger of Truth, November 2, 1854, [3].↩

  10. For an overview of this period including the significance of the 1850 chart, see Michael W. Campbell, “Bible Conferences, 1848-1851,” in the Encyclopedia of Seventh-day Adventists, last modified February 1, 2024, https://encyclopedia.adventist.org/article?id=BIR3&highlight=bible|conferences.↩

  11. See letter published in ARH, September 16, 1851, 32.↩

  12. See note ARH, April 21, 1851, 72.↩

  13. See letter from H. S. Case dated April 17, 1851, with James White’s subsequent comment. ARH, May 5, 1851, 80.↩

  14. See letter by R. Phelps, April 21, 1851, ARH, May 19, 1851, 88.↩

  15. See note in ARH, February 3, 1852, 88.↩

  16. H. S. Case, “From Bro. Case,” [July 8, 1852], ARH, July 22, 1852, 46.↩

  17. See under “Appointments,” ARH, September 16, 1852, 80.↩

  18. J. H. W[aggoner], “The Third Angel’s Message: Fourth Paper,” ARH, April 10, 1883, 234.↩

  19. James White, “Western Tour,” ARH, June 9, 1853, 12.↩

  20. Ibid.↩

  21. H. S. Case, “From Bro. Case,” ARH, February 17, 1853, 158.↩

  22. Ibid.↩

  23. See note in ARH, August 11, 1853, 56.↩

  24. See Arthur L. White, Ellen G. White: The Early Years: 1827-1862 (Hagerstown, MD: Review and Herald, 1985), 1:276. See also Ellen G. White, “A Vision Given at Jackson, Michigan, June 2, 1853,” Manuscript 1, 1853; J. N. Loughborough, “Some Individual Experience,” unpublished manuscript, circa 1919, 558-560; J. Morrill, “From Sister Morrill,” Messenger of Truth, November 30, 1854, [4]; Ellen G. White Letters and Manuscripts with Annotations (Hagerstown, MD: Review and Herald, 2014), 1:360, fn. 23.↩

  25. M. Ellsworth Olsen, A History of the Origin and Progress of Seventh-day Adventists.2nd ed. (Washington, DC: Review and Herald, 1926), 225.↩

  26. The participation of Charles P. Russell is often overlooked. For more information about Russell, see his obituary: “Death of a Pioneer,” Jackson Citizen Patriot, December 5, 1879, 2.↩

  27. Ellen G. White, Spiritual Gifts, 2:181; see also White, Life Sketches (1880) 302 and White, Life Sketches (1888), 302.↩

  28. J. N. Loughborough, “Some Individual Experience,” unpublished manuscript, circa 1919, 558-560.↩

  29. Ellen G. White, Spiritual Gifts: My Christian Experience, Views and Labors, in Connection with the Rise and Progress of the Third Angel’s Message (Battle Creek, MI: James White, 1860), 2:181.↩

  30. Arthur Whitefield Spalding, Captains of the Host: First Volume of a History of Seventh-day Adventists Covering the Years 1845-1900 (Washington, D.C.: Review and Herald, 1949), 208.↩

  31. H. S. Case,” ARH, April 18, 1854, 102.↩

  32. Ibid.↩

  33. James White, “Western Tour,” ARH, May 23, 1854, 141-142.↩

  34. Ibid.↩

  35. Ibid.↩

  36. Dores E. Robinson, “The Signatory Referred to,” The Ministry, June 1939, 22.↩

  37. Paul A. Gordon, “Messengers of Error: A Story form the 1850s Reminds us that History Repeats,” ARH, March 5, 1992, 14-15. Only three extant copies of this periodical are known to exist in the state library of Pennsylvania.↩

  38. George O. States, “Early Recollections in the Third Angel’s Message,” ARH, January 7, 1902, 11.↩

  39. James White, “Western Tour,” ARH, July 4, 1854, 172.↩

  40. George O. States, “Lessons from Past Experiences—No. 2,” ARH, August 9, 1906, 9.↩

  41. J[ames] W[hite], “A Sketch of the Rise and Progress of the Present Truth,” ARH, January 14, 1858, 77.↩

  42. 1860 United States Federal Census, The National Archives in Washington D.C.; Records of the Bureau of the Census; Record Group Number: 29; Series Number: M653; Residence Date: 1860; Home in 1860: De Witt, Clinton, Michigan; Roll: M653_540; Page: 1071, accessed from Ancestry.↩

  43. Paul A. Gordon, “Messengers of Error: A Story form the 1850s Reminds us that History Repeats,” ARH, March 5, 1992, 14-15.↩

  44. “Hiram S. Case,” Find a Grave, accessed July 8, 2026, https://www.findagrave.com/memorial/83470280/hiram_s-case↩

  45. Gary Land, Historical Dictionary of the Seventh-day Adventists (Lanham, MD: The Scarecrow Press, 2005), s.v. “Church of God (Seventh-Day),” 63-64. See also Richard C. Nickels, A History of the Seventh Day Church of God (The Author, 1973), 3, 4, 7.↩

  46. Spalding, Captains of the Host, 208.↩

  47. Allan G. Lindsay, “Thankful for These Stones: How God Worked to Build Up His Remnant People,” ARH, November 23, 2000, 8-11.↩

×

Campbell, Michael W. "Case, Hiram S. (1814–1882)." Encyclopedia of Seventh-day Adventists. November 03, 2026. Accessed November 17, 2026. https://encyclopedia.adventist.org/article?id=F93D.

Campbell, Michael W. "Case, Hiram S. (1814–1882)." Encyclopedia of Seventh-day Adventists. November 03, 2026. Date of access November 17, 2026, https://encyclopedia.adventist.org/article?id=F93D.

Campbell, Michael W. (2026, November 03). Case, Hiram S. (1814–1882). Encyclopedia of Seventh-day Adventists. Retrieved November 17, 2026, https://encyclopedia.adventist.org/article?id=F93D.